ISBN: 978-1-63624-234-7, Casemate Publishers, 2022, $24.95 (Paperback)
Reviewed by: Nancy E. Blacker, National Defense University, Fort McNair, Washington, D.C., United States
If you want to know what it was like to operate behind the lines in Vietnam, then SOG Kontum is the book for you. But the book is much more. It also illuminates how small teams operate under wartime conditions or in any stressful situation. After reading numerous stories of individual acts of bravery, the reader will understand that the common theme running through these disparate wartime stories is that warriors survive through a baseline of shared values and selfless service. In a nutshell, warriors take care of each other.
In SOG Kontum, SOG stands for Studies and Observations Group. In this context, it is part of Military Assistance Command, Vietnam, commonly known as MACV or MACV-SOG. Although this reviewer had certainly heard of MACV, watched Walter Cronkite deliver the evening news almost daily throughout the late 1960s, and read numerous books on the Vietnam War, she had never heard of SOG Kontum. The first few sentences of the book affirm the secrecy of SOG, stating, “The public, of course, never heard of SOG (Studies and observation Group) and very (very) few of those who fought in Vietnam knew of SOG’s existence or its top-secret operations in Laos, Cambodia, and North Vietnam.” Kontum is located near the Ho Chi Minh Trail in the Central Highlands of Vietnam.
Created in 1964 by the Joint Chiefs of Staff, MACV-SOG was “a highly classified multi-service United States special operations unit that engaged in covert unconventional warfare missions during the Vietnam War.” Further reducing the chance that anyone would ever learn about SOG, “its highly classified records were ordered to be destroyed.” After the requisite declassification period ended in 1995, the book’s authors, Joe Parnar and Robert Dumont, set out to find records so they could write about what Parnar had experienced. Parnar served in the U.S. Army Special Forces from August 1966 to April 1969, including with the unit featured in the book, while Dumont worked in the General Research Division of the New York Public Library. To their deep dismay, they discovered that the burn order had been followed and “not one” of the after-action reports had survived. I cannot imagine such disappointment. Searching for records about something you experienced but could not prove must have been like being a descendant of former slaves and not being able to find a birth certificate. Legitimacy is fickle, and proving it is becoming increasingly difficult in an environment filled with electronic noise. Oral histories are important, and these histories are especially important now as the population of Vietnam veterans grows older. With some exceptions, most surviving veterans are in their eighties. It is therefore fortunate that the authors began investigating early enough to speak with survivors of these incredible SOG missions and shed light on their often-unseen work.
The authors are also characters in this book. This adds to the authenticity of the tales and brings their adventures to life. Readers of the special operations genre often imagine themselves in these situations. Could you have accomplished what they did under the harrowing conditions in which they found themselves? Even if you have experienced only military training and not jungle warfare, after reading SOG Kontum, you can better relate to the stories through the rich details shared by the authors. These details may tend to portray the warriors’ actions as heroic, but that portrayal seems justified based on the facts presented.
The best thing about SOG Kontum is that the authors write in a way that allows you to almost feel the situation. This vivid descriptive language must come easily to someone who lived through these events. For example, in describing the difficulty of maintaining sustained radio contact in treacherous terrain, Tony Love is quoted as saying, “…but if I moved a step forward or backward, or even squatted down, I lost contact. I finally had to stand upright and exposed in the same spot a few feet outside the rocks until I could relay the team’s situation….” This paints a picture of danger that you can almost feel. There are also tales that seem almost humorous from the safety of the present day but must have been harrowing in the jungle. For example, one story recounts the sounds of an elephant piercing the night’s silence, not only setting the soldiers on edge because of the noise but also raising concerns that one of these beasts might set off the Claymore mines the team had placed.
Aside from the engrossing mission stories, the authors bring each of the SOG members they identified to life by digging into their childhoods and showing how they grew up, what formed their characters, and what motivated them to serve their country. These stories make the book more interesting by revealing the soldiers’ humanity and what shaped their aspirations. In the narrative accounts of firefights, rescues, and other adventures, the authors also note elements that may seem silly or absurd but that, at the time, made the men laugh and helped relieve the pressure of an incredibly stressful situation. These seemingly trivial anecdotes are relatable to anyone who has experienced combat or any other stressful situation.
The details in SOG Kontum make the book. Each story has unique points, so if readers cannot relate to one, they will likely be able to relate to the next. These tales illuminate how things that seem logical can become a crisis under stress. For example, a plan to resupply ammunition seems like an obvious element of any operation. However, when troops are in contact and the enemy interrupts resupply options, a planned event becomes a crisis. The authors walk the reader through the decisions involved in how a SOG team dealt with such an event. For instance, one story recounts how “…for most of the evening we lay on our backs on the rear edge of the foxhole with our knees dangling down into it so we would have had only to slide in if we were attacked.” This description is all one needs to envision the situation.
After reading the book, I felt as though I truly knew the men of SOG Kontum. The authors tell of those who gave their last full measure, and the book concludes with positive stories about the survivors and what they did after their service. If you crave combat details, including unit names, weaponry, and types of aerial platforms, this is your kind of book. The target audience leans toward Vietnam veterans, but the book also speaks to anyone who wants to understand—as much as one can through a book—the experience of combat. It certainly fills a void in the historical record and honors those who served in a way that is difficult to find in common, antiseptic storytelling. This book makes you feel like part of the adventure, the drama, and the danger. Hopefully, it also subtly conveys the message that attempting to bury the past serves neither those who lived it nor those who might stumble into repeating it.